In light of the COVID-19 pandemic, there is a lot of interest in immune function and what, if anything we can do to strengthen our immune system. Given how susceptible we all feel to this virus, it’s natural and productive to investigate how we can proactively strengthen our immune system.
Unfortunately, there have been attempts by some to capitalize on this vulnerability by claiming bogus supplements and treatments (spinal manipulation, cleanses) will improve your immunity.
This is dangerous and wrong. I want to make this clear: There is no evidence that exercising, taking any supplements or herbs, or dietary change will prevent you from getting the corona virus. Claims to the contrary are absurd and those disseminating such information should be ignored.
However, looking for evidence for ways to boost your immune system so you can better fight off infections in general is a worthwhile investigation.
There are so many benefits of exercise to not only address function and appearance, but also prevent or treat/manage non-communicable diseases. These are the diseases you can’t catch, but they cause millions of deaths and cost billions such as: heart disease, diabetes, cancer, depression, and musculoskeletal disease (arthritis).
But rarely do we talk about exercise in terms of treating communicable disease, infectious diseases. Since such diseases are in the forefront of people’s minds lately, I think it is timely to explore what role, if any, exercise and diet has in managing these issues.
Accordingly, I’d like to share what I’ve found that answers the following questions:
- Does exercise improve your immune function?
- What should you do when you are sick?
- Does your diet improve your immune system?
- Do supplements improve your immune system?
I’ll start with a quick summary. Excellent evidence suggests that exercise, proper nutrition, and adequate sleep are essential for improving immunity. Actions leading to facilitating the above are the best things you can do to improve immune function.
Let’s delve into that a little for more specifics that you can act on.
Does exercise improve your immune function?
Years ago, I reported on the findings of an excellent review on the effects of exercise and immune function. (Rossi et al. Strength and Conditioning Journal, Dec 2010).The conclusion was that those who exercise regularly have significantly reduced incidence of sickness compared to those who do not. Mechanisms were proposed by which this occurs, yielding the conclusion that the effect of this was not solely due to a correlation to the fact that exercisers are generally healthier (less comorbidities, better nutrition, better sleep, etc).
However, it was suggested that the type of exercise mattered. In fact, if the exercise was moderate to high intensity, high frequency, and high volume, then your immune function was actually decreased in the short term, making you more susceptible to illness. This would be the case for an endurance athlete who trains 90 minutes 6 days a week, such as someone training for a triathlon. Some research indicated that this temporary immune system suppression could be counteracted by consuming a carbohydrate and protein drink before, during, and after exercise.
While most people don’t need to worry about this, as their workout duration and frequency are usually far lower than this, it would be concerning if you are an endurance athlete or someone who really likes that type of training.
More resent research calls into question whether high frequency, prolonged exercise actually does decrease the immune system function (Campbel, JP, and Turner, JE Front Immunol. 2018). They took a deep dive into the research regarding exercise and the immune system and addressed the notion that longer duration or higher intensity exercise suppressed the immune system.
Their review of the evidence yields some interesting conclusions:
- High intensity/frequency/duration exercise does not suppress the immune system. It seems researchers citing otherwise misinterpreted salivary levels of IgA (an antibody that plays a critical role in immune function) as a signal of decreased immune function, which it does not. Also, prior research misinterpreted the decrease in lymphocyte numbers and function for 1-2 hours post exercise as an indication of immune suppression. Instead, what is really happening is that these immune cells are mobilized to the peripheral tissues “resulting in a heightened state of immune surveillance and immune regulation, as opposed to immune suppression.” So it seems that you endurance folks don’t need to be so worried about that.
- They reaffirm that frequent exercise heightens immune functioning, and that frequent exercisers have better responses to bacterial and viral antigens following bouts of exercise.
- They provide evidence that regular exercise may limit or delay the aging of the immune system. This is critical for older adults, who as we all are now more aware, have a less effective immune system.
This means that endurance athletes don’t need to worry that their activity will make them more vulnerable to infections. Frequent exercisers can add a stronger immune system to the list of benefits of being active. And if you want to keep your immune system functioning well as you age, you should definitely exercise more.
What about when you are already sick, should you still exercise?
There is a rule of thumb in the medical community that goes like this:
- If you have symptoms above the neck, exercise is fine.
- If you have symptoms below the neck, stop and rest
- If you have a fever, don’t exercise.
This is ok, but there are some problems. So I’m going to create my own rules that I think more accurately reflects the research and experience from someone that exercises and prescribes routines for a living:
- If you have a fever, don’t exercise. Rest – a lot. Don’t stretch. Don’t stay home and work from your laptop in bed or answer emails. Simply rest or you will be sick longer.
- If you have GI symptoms – Well, I don’t think I need to tell you what to do about that, so I’ll move on.
- For other symptoms, I’ll break it down based on type of exercise and personality type:
Resistance training: low to high intensity, low volume (1-2 sets per exercise, 3-6 exercises) low frequency (1-3 sessions) low duration (20-40 minutes) low rest periods (2-4 minutes between sets)
Corrective exercises: definitely fine
Dynamic warm-up: Definitely fine
Energy system training: Moderate intensity (under 80% max simply rated at less than an 8 out of 10 – ten being an all-out maximum), low duration, moderate frequency (3-4 times a week).
Beginners/fat loss: Focus on rest, diet, corrective exercise, dynamic warm-ups, and resistance training as above. I tend to give more encouragement for these clients to exercise when they are symptomatic (again, not if they have fevers). Mostly because their exercise habit is fragile, and also they aren’t capable of exercising at the intensities that cause over training and immune compromise.
You won’t burn a bunch of calories now, so this is not the time to push to new limits. But this might be the time to keep the routine of your new and perhaps fragile fitness commitment intact. At this stage, the focus is on learning the routine via proper technique anyways, and you can always push the sets and reps later. If symptoms allow, don’t back off how much weight you use. But cut out some sets, allow plenty of rest between sets. Circuit training and complexes may need to be backed down a bit. Intervals can be tolerated very well, but your work phase will not be nearly as intense.
Endurance athletes: I like them to take time off completely. They tend to be overworked and over trained, and the endorphin high of training is too tempting to trust them to not chase it. However, if they must train (which I totally get – stress release, etc), again I suggest they focus on corrective exercise and some resistance training. Most will lose it mentally if they don’t do some aerobics, so they are advised to do so with very low intensity 20-30 minute walks or rides. Best to do this inside if they have chest congestion and it is very cold out, as this can irritate the respiratory tract.
Strength athletes: Pretty much the same as the beginner/fat loss people, and there is somewhat of a mental issue here as well – but not like with the endurance athletes. The big difference is that training with weights at 70% of their max can still be tough to handle if they have sinus issues because the strength capacities are so high proportionate to others. Just because you can bench 300 pounds doesn’t mean your sinus cavities are 300% stronger than when you could only bench 150lbs! It also depends on positions. For example, bench press and bent over rows may make your head feel like exploding. But lunges and chins might be fine because you are upright. On the other hand, if you have chest symptoms you’ll be fine as long as you stay away from complexes, circuits, high reps, and low rests which tax the respiratory system too much.
Does your diet improve your immune system?
Every resource suggests that a healthy diet, including adequate macro (protein, fats, and carbohydrates) and micronutrients (vitamins and minerals), is required for a healthy immune system. There are clear associations with poor immune function in those suffering with malnutrition.
However, very little quality research exists that tells us what precise healthy diet is best for boosting immune function. A very recent review highlighted this problem. While some studies indicate certain nutrients like fiber, healthy fats, and proteins are important in enhancing immune function, not enough interventional research on humans is available to give specific recommendations and give strong conclusions. (Venter, C. eta l, Nutrients Mar 19 2020.)
While that won’t stop many from veraciously touting specialized diets to boost your immune system, the facts are that we just don’t have enough research to back that up.
Meanwhile, continue to focus on eating healthy in a way that is sustainable for you and ignore strong claims to make changes based on enhancing your immunity until better research is available.
Do supplements improve your immune system?
Many studies have been done on the effects of supplements on improving immunity or your ability to recover from illnesses such as colds. The research suggests that Vitamin C, Zinc, Vitamin D and seem to offer positive effects on either warding off infections or lessening symptoms. The research is backed by moderate quality evidence.
For example, a meta-analysis in 2018 showed that supplementing with vitamin C can shorten the duration of a cold and lessen symptoms. It’s important to note that this effect seems to occur only when you’ve been supplementing regularly, and likely won’t make a difference if you start when you’ re already sick. (Ran L, et al Biomed Res Int. 2018)
Vitamin D supplementation seems to prevent upper respiratory infections. ( Martineau AR, et al.. BMJ. 2017)
Zinc lozenges taken upon the onset of symptoms has reduced the duration of illness, but should be less that 100mg for less than 2 weeks to avoid GI and other side effects.
I’d strongly recommend that you take a look at my go-to resource, examine.com. It is run by a trusted industry leader who hires top tier scientists to intensely research the quality of studies and dissect their conclusions. They then report their findings in readable form so we can all make educated decisions on supplements. They do not sell nor promote any supplements. They just report on the evidence, which is a great service. Take a look here for more research on the topic of supplements and immune function. They will have everything you need to know based on solid evidence.
We are all concerned about our immune system, especially now. It’s important that we all do what we can to enhance our immune function and learn about The benefits of Mindfulness while not falling prey to poor evidence and unsubstantiated claims.
You can be confident that exercise will play a critical role in enhancing your immune system. Your diet will likely help, but no need to switch to anything beyond one that allows you to eat a healthy amount of protein, fats, and carbs, emphasizing fiber and nutrient rich foods like vegetables and fruit. And while some supplements might work, the evidence is moderate.
As always, please reach out to us to help you improve your health and fitness. Right now, we are looking for 20 people who are stuck and home and want to take control of their circumstance by emerging from the corona virus pandemic healthier and stronger in the next 60 days. If interested, please go here for details